Federal Court Decisions

Decision Information

Castorena Garcia v. Canada (Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness)

Court (s) Database Federal Court Decisions
Date 2010-12-31
Neutral citation 2010 FC 1341
File numbers IMM-7710-10

Decision Content

 

Federal Court

 

Cour fédérale


Date: 20101231

Docket: IMM-7710-10

Citation: 2010 FC 1341

Ottawa , Ontario , December 31, 2010

PRESENT:  The Honourable Madam Justice Tremblay-Lamer

 

BETWEEN:

 

DANIEL CASTORENA GARCIA

 

 

 

Applicant

 

and

 

 

 

THE MINISTER OF PUBLIC SAFETY AND EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS

 

 

 

Respondent

 

 

 

 

 

  REASONS FOR ORDER AND ORDER

 

 

  • [1] First, regardless of the merits of the applicant’s motion, the Court is not inclined to exercise its discretion favourably in order to grant this equitable remedy for someone who does not come with clean hands.

 

  • [2] The applicant failed to appear for removal in April 2010; and despite being given the benefit of the doubt for this failure to appear and being advised of the importance of respecting the conditions of his release, he failed to report his change of address when he moved out in October 2010 and failed to appear in November 2010, which lead to a warrant for his arrest.

 

  • [3] The applicant’s behaviour shows complete disregard for Canada ’s immigration laws.Further, I would add that had I decided this matter on its merits, I would have found that the applicant has failed to demonstrate any irreparable harm.His own evidence shows that even if he stays in Canada to complete his school year, he may have to repeat his school year in Mexico , regardless.

 

  • [4] As stated by Justice Marc Nadon in Mahadeo v. Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration, (1999), 166 F.T.R. 315, 86 A.C.W.S. (3d) 773 (Fed. T.D.) at para. 5:

 

 

  Leaving school before the completion of the school year will no doubt be highly inconvenient and will most likely necessitate the redoing of their school year.  However, this does not constitute irreparable harm.

 

 

  • [5] For these reasons, the motion for a stay is dismissed.

 

 

 

 


ORDER

 

THIS COURT ORDERS that the motion be dismissed.

 

 

“Danièle Tremblay-Lamer”

Judge


FEDERAL COURT

 

SOLICITORS OF RECORD

 

 

DOCKET:  IMM-7710-10

 

STYLE OF CAUSE:  DANIEL CASTORENAGARCIA

  Applicant

  and

 

  THE MINISTER OF PUBLIC SAFETY AND EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS

 

 

 

PLACE OF HEARING:  Ottawa , Ontario

 

DATE OF HEARING:  December 31, 2010

 

REASONS FOR ORDER:  TREMBLAY-LAMER J.

 

DATED:  December 31, 2010

 

 

 

APPEARANCES:

 

Daniel Kingwell

 

FOR THE APPLICANT

 

Suran Bhattacharyya

FOR THE RESPONDENT

 

 

SOLICITORS OF RECORD:

 

Mamann, Sandaluk

Toronto , Ontario

 

FOR THE APPLICANT

Attorney General of Canada

Toronto , Ontario

FOR THE RESPONDENT

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 You are being directed to the most recent version of the statute which may not be the version considered at the time of the judgment.